Old Venus by George R.R. MartinMy rating: 4 of 5 stars
I grew up with the stories of the old Solar System from before the first interplanetary probes destroyed the dreams of finding new life and new civilizations right in our astronomical backyard. The worlds where Mars was home to an older and wiser civilization, where Venus was a swampy world of monsters and beautiful people. Where action and adventure was only a few weeks or months away, rather than a centuries-long journey to another star. In our small-town library, books stayed on the shelves until they began to disintegrate, so the classics of SF didn't disappear simply because they had become dated.
And this anthology was like going back down memory lane. I really loved the story that was openly set in the world of CL Moore's Northwest Smith stories, which have fallen into the public domain because of the rules at the time about renewal of copyright. There were other stories that had the flavor of various major authors, from Heinlein's First Future History version of Venus to Edgar Rice Burroughs' Carson of Venus novels, without actually using any copyrighted IP. Other stories gave a nod to the New Venus. In one story, the protagonist travels not only through space, but also through time to a past when Venus was still a lush and dangerous water world. In another, the characters live in a far future when Venus has been terraformed, rather like David Drake's Seas of Venus novels. And the final one seemed to be a retelling of the old action-adventure stories of travel to distant and exotic lands, the sort that are now condemned as Orientalizing and exoticizing -- but since Venusians manifestly do not exist, it's able to fly under the watchful eye of the SJW moral watchdogs.
There was only one story I truly Did Not Like. That's the Bernie Wooster pastiche, which grated on my nerves. By the time I got through it, I was thoroughly sick of all the "right ho" and "what ho" and quite glad to be done with it. However, that's probably more of a personal taste thing, and someone who's a Bernie Wooster fan and also loves stories of the Old Solar System of the pre-spaceflight pulps would probably get a real kick out of it.
View all my reviews
Posts
